{
    "componentChunkName": "component---src-templates-post-type-legal-interventions-js",
    "path": "/legal-interventions/r-v-fenech-murone-and-fenech-county-court-mar-2009/",
    "result": {"data":{"wpgraphql":{"page":{"title":"R v Fenech, Murone and Fenech (County Court) &#8211; Mar 2009","uri":"legal-interventions/r-v-fenech-murone-and-fenech-county-court-mar-2009/","databaseId":2369,"acfPageHeader":{"layout":"standard","title":null,"introduction":null,"seoTitle":"R v Fenech, Murone and Fenech (County Court) - Mar 2009 ","seoDescription":"This case involved criminal charges for trafficking and possession of drugs of dependence under the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981. A preliminary issue for determination was whether the County Court should exercise its discretion to refer a question to the Supreme Court regarding the interpretation of section 5 of the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 compatibly with the human rights in the Charter.","seoImage":null,"image":null,"buttonLink":null,"buttonColour":"default"},"appBreadcrumb":[{"title":"Home","link":"/"}],"acfTableOfContents":{"tableOfContents":null},"acfBodyContent":{"bodyContent":[{"__typename":"WPGraphQL_LegalIntervention_Acfbodycontent_BodyContent_Wysiwyg","contentHeading":"About the intervention ","content":"<p>This case involved criminal charges for trafficking and possession of drugs of dependence under the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981. A preliminary issue for determination was whether the County Court should exercise its discretion to refer a question to the Supreme Court regarding the interpretation of section 5 of the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 compatibly with the human rights in the Charter.</p>\n<p>The Commission intervened to make submissions on the considerations relevant to a referral decision. The Commission submitted that questions should only be referred to the Supreme Court where they are significant and important, as a lower threshold for referral runs the risk of excluding lower courts from the human rights dialogue envisaged by the Charter.</p>\n<p>The County Court decided against exercising its discretion to refer the question for determination by the Supreme Court.</p>\n"}]},"acfRichContent":{"richContent":[{"__typename":"WPGraphQL_LegalIntervention_Acfrichcontent_RichContent_Downloads","title":"Download attachments ","introduction":"","downloads":[{"download":{"title":"R v Fenech, Murone and Fenech &#8211; Submissions","fileSizeFormatted":"94kB","fileTypeFormatted":"PDF","sourceRemote":"https://cms.humanrights.vic.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Intervention-R_v_Fenech_Murone_and_Fenech-Substantive_Submissions-Mar_2009.pdf","sourceLocal":{"publicURL":"/static/e40d3fa0251467c232d53de21eb34814/Intervention-R_v_Fenech_Murone_and_Fenech-Substantive_Submissions-Mar_2009.pdf"}}},{"download":{"title":"R v Fenech, Murone and Fenech &#8211; Submissions on Section 33","fileSizeFormatted":"29kB","fileTypeFormatted":"PDF","sourceRemote":"https://cms.humanrights.vic.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Intervention-R_v_Fenech_Murone_and_Fenech-Submissions_on_s33-Mar_2009.pdf","sourceLocal":{"publicURL":"/static/337caa850e1461e7ef871af83c58e1e4/Intervention-R_v_Fenech_Murone_and_Fenech-Submissions_on_s33-Mar_2009.pdf"}}}]}]}}}},"pageContext":{"id":"bGVnYWwtaW50ZXJ2ZW50aW9uOjIzNjk=","title":"R v Fenech, Murone and Fenech (County Court) &#8211; Mar 2009","link":"https://cms.humanrights.vic.gov.au/legal-interventions/r-v-fenech-murone-and-fenech-county-court-mar-2009/"}},
    "staticQueryHashes": ["1001322823","130765067","1964591631","3000541721","3854666041","3896819453"]}